Showing posts with label Adolescence News. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Adolescence News. Show all posts

Adolescence

Definition

Sometimes referred to as teenage years, youth, or puberty , adolescence is the transitional period between childhood and maturity, occurring roughly between the ages of 10 and 20.

Description

The word adolescence is Latin in origin, derived from the verb adolescere, which means "to grow into adulthood." Adolescence is a time of moving from the immaturity of childhood into the maturity of adulthood. There is no single event or boundary line that denotes the end of childhood or the beginning of adolescence. Rather, experts think of the passage from childhood into and through adolescence as composed of a set of transitions that unfold gradually and that touch upon many aspects of the individual's behavior, development, and relationships. These transitions are biological, cognitive, social, and emotional.

Puberty

The biological transition of adolescence, or puberty, is perhaps the most observable sign that adolescence has begun. Technically, puberty refers to the period during which an individual becomes capable of sexual reproduction. More broadly speaking, however, puberty is used as a collective term to refer to all the physical changes that occur in the growing girl or boy as the individual passes from childhood into adulthood.

The timing of physical maturation varies widely. In the United States, menarche (onset of menstruation ) typically occurs around age 12, although some youngsters start puberty when they are only eight or nine, others when they are well into their teens. The duration of puberty also varies greatly: 18 months to six years in girls and two to five years in boys.

The physical changes of puberty are triggered by hormones, chemical substances in the body that act on specific organs and tissues. In boys a major change incurred during puberty is the increased production of testosterone, a male sex hormone, while girls experience increased production of the female hormone estrogen. In both sexes, a rise in growth hormone produces the adolescent growth spurt, the pronounced increase in height and weight that marks the first half of puberty.

Perhaps the most dramatic changes of puberty involve sexuality. Internally, through the development of primary sexual characteristics, adolescents become capable of sexual reproduction. Externally, as secondary sexual characteristics appear, girls and boys begin to look like mature women and men. In boys primary and secondary sexual characteristics usually emerge in a predictable order, with rapid growth of the testes and scrotum, accompanied by the appearance of pubic hair. About a year later, when the growth spurt begins, the penis also grows larger, and pubic hair becomes coarser, thicker, and darker. Later still comes the growth of facial and body hair, and a gradual lowering of the voice. Around mid-adolescence internal changes begin making a boy capable of producing and ejaculating sperm.

In girls, sexual characteristics develop in a less regular sequence. Usually, the first sign of puberty is a slight elevation of the breasts, but sometimes this is preceded by the appearance of pubic hair. Pubic hair changes from sparse and downy to denser and coarser. Concurrent with these changes is further breast development . In teenage girls, internal sexual changes include maturation of the uterus, vagina, and other parts of the reproductive system. Menarche, the first menstrual period, happens relatively late in puberty. Regular ovulation and the ability to carry a baby to full term usually follow menarche by several years.

Cognitive transition

A second element of the passage through adolescence is a cognitive transition. Compared to children, adolescents think in ways that are more advanced, more efficient, and generally more complex. This is evident in five distinct areas of cognition.

First, during adolescence individuals become better able than children to think about what is possible, instead of limiting their thought to what is real. Whereas children's thinking is oriented to the here and now (i.e., to things and events that they can observe directly), adolescents are able to consider what they observe against a backdrop of what is possible—they can think hypothetically.

Second, during the passage into adolescence, individuals become better able to think about abstract ideas. For example, adolescents find it easier than children to comprehend the sorts of higher-order, abstract logic inherent in puns, proverbs, metaphors, and analogies. The adolescent's greater facility with abstract thinking also permits the application of advanced reasoning and logical processes to social and ideological matters. This is clearly seen in the adolescent's increased facility and interest in thinking about interpersonal relationships, politics, philosophy, religion, and morality—topics that involve such abstract concepts as friendship, faith, democracy, fairness, and honesty.

Third, during adolescence individuals begin thinking more often about the process of thinking itself, or metacognition. As a result, adolescents may display increased introspection and self-consciousness. Although improvements in metacognitive abilities provide important intellectual advantages, one potentially negative byproduct of these advances is the tendency for adolescents to develop a sort of egocentrism, or intense preoccupation with the self. Acute adolescent egocentrism sometimes leads teenagers to believe that others are constantly watching and evaluating them. Psychologists refer to this as the imaginary audience.

A fourth change in cognition is that thinking tends to become multidimensional, rather than limited to a single issue. Whereas children tend to think about things one aspect at a time, adolescents describe themselves and others in more differentiated and complicated terms and find it easier to look at problems from multiple perspectives. Being able to understand that people's personalities are not one-sided, or that social situations can have different interpretations, depending on one's point of view, permits the adolescent to have far more sophisticated and complicated relationships with other people.

Finally, adolescents are more likely than children to see things as relative, rather than absolute. They are more likely to question others' assertions and less likely to accept "facts" as absolute truths. This increase in relativism can be particularly exasperating to parents, who may feel that their adolescent children question everything just for the sake of argument.

Emotional transition

Adolescence is also a period of emotional transition, marked by changes in the way individuals view themselves and in their capacity to function independently. As adolescents mature intellectually and undergo cognitive changes, they come to perceive themselves in more sophisticated and differentiated ways. Compared with children, who tend to describe themselves in relatively simple, concrete terms, adolescents are more likely to employ complex, abstract, and psychological self-characterizations. As individuals' self-conceptions become more abstract and as they become more able to see themselves in psychological terms, they become more interested in understanding their own personalities and why they behave the way they do.

For most adolescents, establishing a sense of autonomy, or independence, is as important a part of the emotional transition out of childhood as is establishing a sense of identity. During adolescence, there is a movement away from the dependency typical of childhood toward the autonomy typical of adulthood. For example, older adolescents do not generally rush to their parents whenever they are upset, worried, or in need of assistance. They do not see their parents as all-knowing or all-powerful, and often have a great deal of emotional energy wrapped up in relationships outside the family . In addition, older adolescents are able to see and interact with their parents as people, not just as their parents. Many parents find, for example, that they can confide in their adolescent children, something that was not possible when their children were younger, or that their adolescent children can easily sympathize with them when they have had a hard day at work.

Being independent, however, means more than merely feeling independent. It also means being able to make decisions and to select a sensible course of action. This is an especially important capability in contemporary society, where many adolescents are forced to become independent decision makers at an early age. In general, researchers find that decision-making abilities improve over the course of the adolescent years, with gains continuing well into the later years of high school.

Many parents wonder about the susceptibility of adolescents to peer pressure . In general, studies that contrast parent and peer influences indicate that in some situations, peers' opinions are more influential, while in others, parents' are more influential. Specifically, adolescents are more likely to conform to their peers' opinions when it comes to short-term, day-to-day, and social matters—styles of dress, tastes in music, and choices among leisure activities. This is particularly true during junior high school and the early years of high school. When it comes to long-term questions concerning educational or occupational plans, however, or values, religious beliefs, and ethical issues, teenagers are influenced in a major way by their parents.

Susceptibility to the influence of parents and peers changes during adolescence. In general, during childhood, boys and girls are highly oriented toward their parents and less so toward their peers; peer pressure during the early elementary school years is not especially strong. As they approach adolescence, however, children become somewhat less oriented toward their parents and more oriented toward their peers, and peer pressure begins to escalate. During early adolescence, conformity to parents continues to decline and conformity to peers and peer pressure continues to rise. It is not until middle adolescence that genuine behavioral independence emerges, when conformity to parents as well as peers declines.

Social transition

Accompanying the biological, cognitive, and emotional transitions of adolescence are important changes in the adolescent's social relationships. Developmentalists have spent considerable time charting the changes that take place with friends and with family members as the individual moves through the adolescent years.
One of the most noteworthy aspects of the social transition into adolescence is the increase in the amount of time individuals spend with their peers. Although relations with age-mates exist well before adolescence, during the teenage years they change in significance and structure. For example, there is a sharp increase during adolescence in the sheer amount of time individuals spend with their peers and in the relative time they spend in the company of peers versus adults. In the United States, well over half of the typical adolescent's waking hours are spent with peers, as opposed to only 15 percent with adults, including parents. Second, during adolescence, peer groups function much more often without adult supervision than they do during childhood, and more often involve friends of the opposite sex.
Finally, whereas children's peer relationships are limited mainly to pairs of friends and relatively small groups—three or four children at a time, for example—adolescence marks the emergence of larger groups of peers, or crowds. Crowds are large collectives of similarly stereotyped individuals who may or may not spend much time together. In contemporary American high schools, typical crowds are "jocks," "brains," "nerds," "populars," "druggies," and so on. In contrast to cliques, crowds are not settings for adolescents' intimate interactions or friendships, but instead serve to locate the adolescent (to himself and to others) within the social structure of the school. As well, the crowds themselves tend to form a sort of social hierarchy or map of the school, and different crowds are seen as having different degrees of status or importance.

The importance of peers during early adolescence coincides with changes in individuals' needs for intimacy. As children begin to share secrets with their friends, loyalty and commitment develop. During adolescence, the search for intimacy intensifies, and self-disclosure between best friends becomes an important pastime. Teenagers, especially girls, spend a good deal of time discussing their innermost thoughts and feelings, trying to understand one another. The discovery that they tend to think and feel the same as someone else becomes another important basis of friendship.

One of the most important social transitions that takes place in adolescence concerns the emergence of sexual and romantic relationships. In contemporary society, most young people begin dating sometime during early adolescence. Dating during adolescence can mean a variety of different things, from group activities that bring males and females together (without much actual contact between the sexes); to group dates, in which a group of boys and girls go out jointly (and spend part of the time as couples and part of the time in large groups); to casual dating as couples; and to serious involvement with a steady boyfriend or girlfriend. More adolescents have experience in mixed-sex group activities like parties or dances than dating, and more have experience in dating than in having a serious boyfriend or girlfriend.

Most adolescents' first experience with sex falls into the category of "autoerotic behavior," sexual behavior that is experienced alone. The most common autoerotic activities reported by adolescents are erotic fantasies and masturbation . By the time most adolescents are in high school, they have had some experience with sexual behaviors in the context of a relationship. The Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance System (YRBSS), a self-reported survey of a national representative sample of high school students in grades nine to 12, indicated that in 2003, 46.7 percent of the students reported having had sex. By grade level, the rates were 32.8 percent for ninth grade, 44.1 percent for tenth grade, 53.2 percent for eleventh grade, and 61.6 percent for twelfth grade.

Common problems

Generally speaking, most young people are able to negotiate the biological, cognitive, emotional, and social transitions of adolescence successfully. Some adolescents, however, are at risk of developing certain problems, such as:
  • eating disorders such as anorexia nervosa , bulimia, or obesity
  • drug or alcohol use
  • depression or suicidal ideation
  • violent behavior
  • anxiety, stress, or sleep disorders
  • unsafe sexual activities

Parental concerns

Many parents dread the onset of adolescence, fearing that their child will become hostile and rebellious and begin to reject his or family. Although it is incorrect to characterize adolescence as a time when the family ceases to be important, or as a time of inherent and inevitable family conflict, adolescence is a period of significant change and reorganization in family relationships. Family relationships change most around the time of puberty, with increasing conflict and decreasing closeness occurring in many parent-adolescent relationships. Changes in the ways adolescents view family rules and regulations may contribute to increased disagreement between them and their parents. Family conflict during this stage is more likely to take the form of bickering over day-to-day issues than outright fighting. Similarly, the diminished closeness is more likely to be manifested in increased privacy on the part of the adolescent and diminished physical affection between teenagers and parents, rather than any serious loss of love or respect between parents and children. Research suggests that this distancing is temporary, and that family relationships may become less conflicted and more intimate during late adolescence.

When to call the doctor

Although changes—biologically, cognitively, emotionally, and socially—are to be expected during adolescence, certain inappropriate behaviors, drastic changes in personality or physical appearance, or abnormal sexual development may warrant a phone call to a physician or counselor. These include:
  • extreme changes in weight (loss or gain) or excessive dieting
  • sleep disturbances
  • social withdrawal or loss of interest in activities
  • sudden personality changes
  • signs of alcohol or drug use
  • talk or threats of suicide
  • violent or aggressive behavior
  • atypical (early or late) onset of puberty; in girls, failure to menstruate by the age of 16

KEY TERMS

Anorexia nervosa —An eating disorder marked by an unrealistic fear of weight gain, self-starvation, and distortion of body image. It most commonly occurs in adolescent females.
Bulimia nervosa —An eating disorder characterized by binge eating and inappropriate compensatory behavior, such as vomiting, misusing laxatives, or excessive exercise.
Hormone —A chemical messenger secreted by a gland or organ and released into the bloodstream. It travels via the bloodstream to distant cells where it exerts an effect.
Menarche —The first menstrual cycle in a girl's life.
Metacognition —Awareness of the process of cognition.

Resources

BOOKS

Steinberg, L. Adolescence, 4th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1996.

PERIODICALS

Blondell, Richard D., Michael B. Foster, and Kamlesh C. Dave. "Disorders of Puberty." American Family Physician 60 (July 1999): 209-24.
Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. "Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance: United States, 2003." Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 53, no. SS-2 (May 21, 2004): 12-20.

ORGANIZATIONS

American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. 3615 Wisconsin Ave. NW, Washington, DC 20016-3007. (202) 966-7300. Web site: http://www.aacap.org.
Society for Research on Adolescence, 3131 S. State St., Suite 302, Ann Arbor, MI 48108-1623. Web site: http://www.s-ra.org.

WEB SITES

Paulu, Nancy. "Helping Your Child through Adolescence." U.S. Department of Education. August 2002 [cited December 31, 2004]. Available online at: http://www.ed.gov/parents/academic/help/adolescence/index.html.
Rutherford, Kim. "A Parent's Guide to Surviving Adolescence." KidsHealth. June 2002 [cited December 31, 2004]. Available online at: http://kidshealth.org/parent/growth/growing/adolescence.html.
Laurence Steinberg, Ph.D. Stephanie Dionne Sherk

Anti-Social Behavior In Girls Predicts Adolescent Depression Seven Years Later

adolescence in girls ~ Anti-Social Behavior In Girls Predicts Adolescent Depression Seven Years Later : Past behavior is generally considered to be a good predictor of future behavior, but new research indicates that may not be the case in the development of depression, particularly among adolescent girls.

University of Washington social scientists tracked first- and second-graders for seven years and found that anti-social behavior among girls and anxiety among both sexes predicted depression in early adolescence. Surprisingly, early signs of depression were not predictive of adolescent depression.

"Anti-social behavior has typically been viewed as a big problem among boys, so it tends to be ignored among girls. Boys with early anti-social behavior typically go on to show more anti-social behavior while girls may turn inward with symptoms, morphing into other mental health problems such as depression eating disorders, anxiety and suicidal behavior during adolescence ," said James Mazza, a UW professor of educational psychology and lead author of the new study. He is currently serving as the past president of the American Association of Suicidology.

"When all the risk factors were analyzed, anti-social behavior and anxiety were the most predictive of later depression. It just may be that they are more prevalent in the early elementary school years than depression." He noted that depression and anxiety share a number of symptoms.

Mazza said that early adolescence is when the first episode of depression typically occurs and that's when it has been noted that gender difference occur, with more girls than boys experiencing depressive symptoms. Children can be assessed at 6 and 7 years of age, but depression is not often recognized or diagnosed until the middle school years.

Children in this study were drawn from a larger project looking at the risks for health and behavior problems. That project was conducted by the university's Social Development Research Group, with which Mazza is affiliated. More than 800 children participated in the depression study. Eighty-one percent were white and 54 percent were boys.

Data were collected annually from the children and their parents and teachers when the children were in the first or second grade. The children filled out surveys that measured their levels of depression, anxiety and anti-social behavior, as well as other measures that were not investigated in this study. Parents and teachers filled out questionnaires about the children's anti-social behavior and social competency, which measured such things as the youngsters' abilities to understand other people's feeling, to make new friends and resolve conflicts. Teachers also rated each child's academic performance. In addition, parents filled out questionnaires concerning family and marital conflict, family stress and parental depression.

"One finding from this study that is a mind-grabber is that young children can identify themselves as being anxious and depressed," said Mazza. "When they had scores that were elevated we were a bit surprised because we thought they would say, 'My life is fun and I play a lot.' But they are able to understand and report feeling depressed or anxious, and tell us so. This suggests giving health surveys in early elementary school is a good idea and we should talk to kids in the first and second grades because they can give us valuable information."

----------------------------
Article adapted by Medical News Today from original press release.
----------------------------

The research was funded by the National Institute on Drug Abuse and published in the online edition of The Journal of Early Adolescence. Co-authors of the study are Robert Abbott, Charles Fleming, Tracy Harachi, Jisuk Park, Kevin Haggerty and Richard Catalano of the UW's Social Development Research Group, and Rebecca Cortes, a research scientist in the UW psychology department.

Advocating education of adolescent girls

adolescence in girls ~ Advocating education of adolescent girls : Population Council’s document New Lessons: The Power of Educating Adolescent Girls emphasises on the significance of investing in girls’ education. It argues that this will make them achieve self-sufficiency and help them access better economic opportunities.


An adolescent girl stands at the doorway of adulthood. In that moment, much is decided. If she stays in school, remains healthy, and gains real skills, she will marry later, have fewer and healthier children, and earn an income that she’ll invest back into her family.

But if she follows the path laid down by poverty, she’ll leave school and enter marriage. As a girl mother, an unskilled worker, and an uneducated citizen, she’ll miss out on the opportunity to reach her full human potential.

Investing in girls is the right thing to do on moral, ethical, and human rights grounds. Perhaps no other segment of society globally faces as much exploitation and injustice. Only a tiny fraction of international aid dollars is spent—and spent effectively—on needs specific to adolescent girls.

This report demonstrates that education for girls during adolescence can be transformative, and hence it identifies a broad array of promising educational approaches which should be evaluated for their impact. Adolescent girls in poverty are acutely aware of the obstacles they face, but are full of ambitious, powerful ideas about how to overcome them.

It shows that across the world few programs are specifically designed with the developmental and learning needs of adolescent girls in mind. Little research or programmatic attention has been given to educational quality and relevance, in particular those aspects that may be beneficial to girls, including curricular content.

The document offers evidence on how proven practices, including scholarships for girls and the recruitment and training of female teachers, can increase the number of adolescent girls attending school and highlights the pedagogical approaches that enhance learning and employment.

Key findings highlight:

The benefits of girls’ schooling ripple out within the family, within the community, and across generations.

Continuing education during adolescence is a necessary first step for girls if they are to overcome a history of disadvantage in paid employment and civic life.

If girls are to make the shift from economic dependency to self-sufficiency, universal access to a range of educational opportunities is essential for sustained learning during adolescence, regardless of girls’ prior educational backgrounds.

It gives a “call to action” for governments, education ministries, donors, NGOs, and corporations to collaborate, innovate, and invest in a range of educational opportunities for adolescent girls.

Effect of Mandatory Parental Notification on Adolescent Girls' Use of Sexual Health Care Services

Abstract

Context  Mandatory parental notification for adolescents to obtain prescribed contraceptives is a controversial issue. Recently, legislation that would prohibit prescribed contraceptives for adolescents without parental involvement was introduced in 10 states and the US Congress. 

Objective  To determine the effect of mandatory parental notification for prescribed contraceptives on use of sexual health care services by adolescent girls. 

Design, Setting, and Participants  Girls younger than 18 years and seeking services at all 33 Planned Parenthood family planning clinics in Wisconsin (n = 1118) were surveyed during the spring of 1999. A response rate of 85% was achieved, yielding a sample of 950 girls. 

Main Outcome Measures  Percentages of girls who reported that they would stop using all sexual health care services, delay testing or treatment for human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) or other sexually transmitted diseases (STDs), or discontinue using specific (but not all) services because of parental notification. 

Results  Fifty-nine percent (n = 556) indicated they would stop using all sexual health care services, delay testing or treatment for HIV or other STDs, or discontinue use of specific (but not all) sexual health care services if their parents were informed that they were seeking prescribed contraceptives. Eleven percent indicated they would discontinue or delay STD tests or treatment, even though the survey made it clear that mandatory parental notification would occur only for prescribed contraceptives. Analyses comparing girls of different ages and races and from urban vs rural clinics showed that, although the 17-year-olds and African American girls were significantly less likely to stop using sexual health care services with mandatory parental notification, roughly half of the 17-year-olds (56%) and African American girls (49%) indicated that they would stop using all sexual health care services, delay testing or treatment for HIV or other STDs, or discontinue use of specific (but not all) services with mandatory parental notification.

Conclusion  Mandatory parental notification for prescribed contraceptives would impede girls' use of sexual health care services, potentially increasing teen pregnancies and the spread of STDs.

Anorexia


As defined by the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, fourth edition (DSM-IV;1994), anorexia nervosa is an eating disorder marked by four major symptoms. First, the patient must be less than 85 percent of ideal weight for age, height, and gender. Second, there must be a morbid fear of fat. Third, the person must believe himself or herself to be normal weight or even fat despite emaciation. Finally, the victim should be amenorrheic (i.e., have no menstrual periods) or, in the case of men, show abnormally low levels of testosterone. Anorexia nervosa is considerably more common in women than in men with 80 to 90 percent of the cases diagnosed in adolescence or adulthood being females. The gender difference is somewhat less pronounced in childhood cases, with girls being approximately five times more likely than boys to suffer from the disorder. Less than 1 percent of the postpubertal female population suffers from anorexia nervosa. It is more common among white than African-American girls and women.

Anorexia nervosa has two ages of peak onset: around age fourteen, and at about age eighteen. The frequency of adolescent onset has led theorists to suggest that the developmental transitions to ADOLESCENCE and to adulthood present special risks for girls, making them more vulnerable than boys are not only to anorexia nervosa but also bulimia nervosa and depression. The combination of age and gender factors has also led theorists to suggest that cultural variables, such as the thin body ideal for females and the relative lack of power among women, contributes to the disorder. Finally, it is clear that anorexia nervosa typically starts in a pattern of either dieting or excessive exercise which itself is probably rooted in an attempt to achieve a particular body shape.

There are at least two paths that lead to the modern definition of anorexia nervosa. The first is self-starvation. The second is a history of defining adolescence and young adulthood as problematic for women. These historical trends meet in the eighteenth century to define anorexia nervosa.

Self-Starvation

Walter Vandereycken and Ron van Deth (1994) suggest that self-starvation is a pervasive phenomenon in human history. Given the cross-cultural and cross-historical presence of self-starvation, it is not surprising that it has many motivations. Perhaps the best-known motives are political and religious. For example, Mahatma Gandhi's lengthy hunger strikes in defiance of British domination of India in the 1930s are well known. Less dramatically, fasting is required of Roman Catholics on certain holy days during Lent and even today, devout Muslims participate in a month-long fast during Ramadan.

The link between religion and self-starvation has received the most attention from students of anorexia nervosa. The link between self-denial, including of food, and spirituality, dates at least as far back as the Egyptian pharaohs. During the fourth and fifth centuries C.E., men went into the Egyptian and Palestinian deserts to dedicate themselves to the worship of Jesus Christ. Self-starvation was part of this dedication. As religious practice was largely limited to men at this time, most of those engaging in religious selfstarvation were men.

Of greater interest in terms of anorexia nervosa is the medieval practice of self-starvation by women, including some young women, in the name of religious piety and purity. By the twelfth century, it was increasingly common for women to participate in religious life and to even be named as saints by the Catholic Church. Many women who ultimatimately became saints engaged in self-starvation, including St. Hedwig of Silesia in the thirteenth century and Catherine of Siena in the fourteenth century. By the time of Catherine of Siena, however, the Church became concerned about extreme fasting as an indicator of spirituality and a path to sainthood. Indeed, Catherine of Siena was told to pray that she would be able to eat again, but was unable to give up fasting.

While there is a long-standing link between self-starvation and piety, there is also a historical relationship between self-starvation and demonic possession or witchcraft. For example, Catherine of Siena ate something everyday so that she would not be labeled a witch. After the middle ages, numerous "fasting saints" were accused of witchcraft under the Inquisition. In some places, women could prove they were not witches if they weighed a sufficient amount on government-designated scales. Again, the relationship between self-starvation and religion was particularly pronounced for women.

The virtually simultaneous designation of self-starvation by women as pious and demonic raises interesting issues concerning the cultural meaning of women's bodies, issues that are still debated in terms of anorexia nervosa. In the calculus of the early twenty-first century, the ideal body type for women is thin. "Supermodels," actresses, and even singers are typically substantially below the weight of the average American woman. Research indicates that this image is so pervasive that even elementary school-age children are aware of it. Studies routinely find that 40 percent of girls in fourth and fifth grade wish they were thinner or worry about getting fat. Yet, if girls take this message too much to heart, dieting severely and actually becoming as thin as the models, they are considered "mentally ill."

Early Adolescent Girls and Illness

Anorexia nervosa is not the first disorder in history marked by unusual eating and amenorrhea that is found predominantly in adolescent or young adult women. According to Brett Silverstein and Deborah Perlick (1995), a paper by Hippocrates, known as On the Disease of Young Women, describes an anorexia nervosa-like disorder. This treatise suggests that the dramatic weight loss is caused by problematic menstrual cycles and recommends marriage and pregnancy as the best treatment.

Similarly, hysteria, a disorder made famous in SIGMUND FREUD's Anna O. case but that was also diagnosed earlier in the nineteenth century, was marked by loss of appetite, depression, and amenorrhea. Neurasthenia was another late nineteenth century "female disorder" involving disordered eating and amenorrhea.
Probably the best known of these disorders of adolescent girls is chlorosis. Chlorosis was made famous by Joan Jacob Brumberg's book Fasting Girls. Brumberg argues that chlorosis, like anorexia nervosa, was a disease of middle-class American girls who were fulfilling the expectations of their culture in an extreme manner. In both the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, such girls developed exaggerated behaviors concerning food. Chlorosis was a form of anemia, found only in girls, that was linked to both the onset of menstruation and physical attractiveness. Oddly, these ill girls were considered particularly attractive, just as the most "beautiful" women in the United States of the early twenty-first century have an anorexic appearance. Chlorotic girls, like those with anorexia nervosa, were likely trying to exercise some control over their own lives and, like anorexic girls, were considered to be suffering from a "nervous" or "psychological" disorder rather than from a primarily physical illness.

By the early twentieth century, chlorosis was no longer being diagnosed in the United States. While it is possible that improved nutrition led to the decline of this form of anemia, it is more likely that culture changes affected the expression of eating-related pathology among adolescent girls. The belief that women were fragile and physically weak generally declined as opportunities for women in jobs, education, and even politics increased. However these changes were not quickly or universally accepted, setting up a clash between images of the "traditional" and the "modern" young woman. Young girls received and internalized these conflicting messages about womanhood and may have sometimes felt unable to control their own destinies or to even know want they wanted to do. One thing they could control, however, was their own eating. This culture-based model resonates with current explanations of the causes of anorexia nervosa.

Anorexia Nervosa

Neither the "fasting saints" nor the "chlorotic girls" were anorexic in the sense that the term is used today. Their self-starvation and "nervous" illness reflected beliefs and women's roles during their historic periods. Although Richard Morton described a case of tuberculosis that resembled anorexia nervosa in 1694, current definitions of the disorder are routinely traced to the work of Sir William Withey Gull and Dr. R. Lasègue, in 1874 and 1873 respectively.

Both Lasègue and Gull describe cases marked by self-starvation and high levels of activity or restlessness. Both note that the problem is particularly pronounced in young women; indeed, Gull suggests that adolescent and young adult women are unusually susceptible to MENTAL ILLNESS. Lasègue notes that these young women are pleased with their food restriction, do not wish to eat more, and do not believe that they are abnormally thin. Lasègue referred to this condition as hysterical anorexia while Gull used the term anorexia nervosa.

Although Gull and Lasègue considered anorexia to be a "nervous" disorder, both treated it medically. Gull in particular seemed to have remarkable success, at least by today's standards, in gradually re-feeding the girls. He reported that his clients recovered their eating habits, weight, and health. Lasègue had more pessimistic reports, noting that patients often went many years without recovering.

It is important to recognize that neither Gull nor Lasègue considered anything resembling a "drive for thinness" as key in the etiology of anorexia nervosa. This focus is a product of the twentieth century, probably instigated by the work of Hilde Bruch. Some practitioners are now questioning the wisdom of the twentieth and twenty-first century emphasis on the role of drive for thinness in anorexia nervosa. They note that in some Asian cultures, particularly Hong Kong and China, drive for thinness does not seem to be part of what otherwise looks like anorexia nervosa. Others note that Gull's success in using medically based treatments ought to encourage us to re-examine the efficacy of such an approach.

Historians have raised a number of issues concerning the emergence of modern anorexia nervosa, which was a trans-Atlantic phenomenon involving both the United States and Western Europe from the mid-nineteenth century onward. The basic issues involve sorting out the "real" disease from its specific historical cause–why the disease emerged when it did– and the fact that it appears so disproportionately in females. The first outcroppings of the modern disease occurred before thinness was widely fashionable, which has prompted consideration of the dynamic of loving, middle-class families in which some young women chose food refusal as a method of rebellion that could not be explicitly articulated. Obviously, the rise of concern for slenderness from about 1900 onward as a fashion standard particularly bearing on women, helped sustain the disease. But the incidence of anorexia was not constant through the twentieth century in the Western world, raising questions about causation and about fluctuations in medical attention. By the 1970s, societal and parental concern about anorexia was widespread, sometimes working against efforts to limit children's food intake in a period when the incidence of childhood obesity was rising more rapidly than anorexia nervosa.

In its current form, anorexia nervosa dates from the midnineteenth century. Yet, it grows out of a long history of self-starvation and female-specific pathologies. As such, it likely is a disorder that can tell us much about the role of young women in today's society and why they opt to wage war against their own bodies.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Andersen, Arnold E. 1985. Practical Comprehensive Treatment of Anorexia Nervosa and Bulimia. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
Brumberg, Joan Jacobs. 1982. "Chlorotic Girls, 1870-1910: An Historical Perspective on Female Adolescence." Child Development 53: 1468-1474.
Brumberg, Joan Jacobs. 1988. Fasting Girls: The Emergence of Anorexia Nervosa. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Silverstein, Brett and Deborah Perlick. 1995. The Cost of Competence: Why Inequality Causes Depression, Eating Disorders, and Illness in Women. New York: Oxford University Press.
Vandereycken, Walter and Ron van Deth. 1994. From Fasting Saints to Anorexic Girls: The History of Self-starvation. New York: New York University Press.

Adolescent Female Aggression


Alison Cunningham, M.A.(Crim.), Director of Research & Planning
Paper presented at the Annual Convention of the Canadian Psychological Association, June 29 to July 1, 2000, Ottawa.

Download this paper in .pdf format here

In December of 1999, Statistics Canada (Savoie, 1999) reported that the arrest rate of female youth for interpersonal offences  - the only national-level proxy we have of violence committed by girls in Canada - has increased twice as fast (+127%) as for their male counterparts (+65%) between 1988 and 1998 while the same figures for adults increased only six percent. When such figures first emerged, observers were reluctant to classify them as a trend. As time passed, they are harder to dismiss as aberrant. Four hypotheses, none of which is mutually exclusive of the others, are commonly presented by way of explanation:
  1. the dramatic nature of the increases is an artifact of the low base rate of female arrests for violence
  2. the increases were triggered by zero tolerance policies for violence which have criminalized behaviour previously dealt with outside the court system
  3. the increases are a reflection of changes in decision-making practices at key junctures in the criminal process including victim reporting and police founding/charging practices
  4. Canadian adolescent women are engaging in violent behaviour more frequently than in the past.
It is not possible to point to empirical evidence to support or refute any of these assertions. Certainly, sensational media reports contribute to the view that a new violent girl is walking the streets of Canada. Reena Virk was only 14-years old when she died in 1997, beaten so severely that she drowned in shallow water. Seven girls, 14 to 16 years old, and one boy were ultimately convicted of various roles in her death. The image of a group of girls swarming and viciously beating another girl, extinguishing a cigarette on her face, was troubling to Canadians. While such a scenario is not uncommon among boys, witness the 1999 beating death of Matti Baranovski in Toronto, we have generally assumed girls are immunized from such behaviour.

Attempts to isolate the precise causes of youth violence inevitably end up by concluding that a complex spectrum of variables is involved (e.g., American Psychological Association, 1993). In other words, youth violence is multi-determined by the interaction of individual factors (e.g., biology, temperament), family factors (e.g., parenting style, exposure to violence in the home), cultural factors such as norms that promote or discourage violence, and situational factors (e.g., access to firearms, gang membership, limited opportunities for pro-social activities). All these factors are affected by social forces such as economic inequalities, prejudices, media representations of violence, attitudes of tolerance toward violence and sex-role stereotyping. Where many of these factors cluster, as they often do in violent adolescents, they are entwined in a package that makes it difficult to untangle the unique contribution and weight of each.

The fact remains, however, that there are only two enduring and powerful correlates of anti-social behaviour including violence. They are age and sex. Violence is overwhelmingly the domain of young men. When we study the violence of male youths - and most studies do this - we miss the opportunity to see the complete picture. Why are girls less prone to violence than boys? Why does the violent behaviour of most violent youth decay over time as they age? In short, the study of youthful female violence is important in its own right but also helps address larger questions of the sources of violence in our society.

In any area of study, methodologies should progress in pace with the state of knowledge, from exploratory to descriptive to causal or relational. Causal research is ultimately most helpful in designing prevention and intervention programs. Research on woman abuse, as an example, started with the case study approach (to document that woman abuse existed), followed by larger scale descriptive studies (to document that the case studies are not isolated and to explicate the dynamics of the phenomenon), to population studies (to gauge incidence and prevalence) and ultimately to theory-testing studies, to determine if our causal postulations are on the right track. These data inform our design of public education strategies and batterer intervention programs (Cunningham et al., 1998).

Recent reviews of studies on adolescent female aggression (Pepler and Craig, 1999; Leschied et al., 2000) demonstrate that there is a small but interesting body of work. These and other studies of violent girls and women are shedding light on a much under-studied topic. Exploratory studies, in which it is wise to include research conducted on clinical and penal samples, have documented that girls can be physically violent. Qualitative studies such as that by Artz (1998) contribute greatly to our understanding of the tapestry of factors that come into play when girls are violent. As Bloom and Covington (1998: 6) note, "feminist theories suggest that focus on gender goes beyond simply adding another variable to the study of female crime." Early efforts to study deviance and anti-social behaviour in women typically juxtaposed them to their male counterparts to examine the differences (e.g., Warren, 1981). Increasingly, females are studied in their own right, to uncover the unique aspects of their behaviour, the motivations and contexts in which those actions occur and how these factors vary among women.

As the media give prominent coverage to the Virk case and others, these research questions have emerged as salient yet unanswered:
  • what is the incidence and prevalence of adolescent female violence in Canada today?
  • are Canadian girls more physically aggressive and violent that in the past?
  • if female violence is on the increase, why is that so?
  • is female aggression caused by different mechanisms than male aggression?
  • what interventions are effective in preventing violence by girls?
  • what interventions are effective in reducing violence among aggressive girls?
This paper proposes ten research activities that collectively would further our understanding of the violent behaviour of young women that builds on the base of previous exploratory, clinical and qualitative work.

1. Longitudinal General Population Studies

Questions about incidence and prevalence of female violence, and how they change over time, can be addressed by population surveys, a methodology employed to study many topics including women abuse, childhood sexual abuse and criminal victimization. In Canada, cross-sectional data from the National Longitudinal Survey of Children and Youth indicate that parents and guardians report lower levels of aggression among girls than among boys age four to 11 (Tremblay et al., 1996). In future years, this research program will examine these children longitudinally, follow them into adolescence and collect information on self-reported aggression. For example, among 12 and 13 year olds, 55% of boys and 27% of girls reported having been in a fight within the past 12 months (Statistics Canada, 1999).

In the United States, the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth in the United States annually interviews a panel sample of 9,000 nationally representative adolescents. Examining the 12-year olds only, 18% of males and 10% of females self-reported committing at least one assault (Puzzanchera, 2000). In most other categories of delinquency, the rates for boys and girls were similar to each other. Another exception was in the behaviour of carrying a handgun, reported to be true by 13% of boys and only 2% of girls. This study will also be able to document changes as the panel ages.

2. Decision-Making Studies to Explore Alternative Hypotheses for Increases in Violent Crime

Because so much emphasis is placed on police statistics as indication that Canadian girls are being more violent of late, it is necessary to examine the factors that construct these figures. It is axiomatic that crime statistics, while national, annual and standardized, are not a valid measure of criminal behaviour (Cunningham and Griffiths, 1997). This is because they are shaped by many factors: the majority of victims do not notify authorities, the police may not feel the incident violates a criminal law (called unfounding), and the police may chose to resolve the matter informally without a charge (e.g., refer the case to a diversion program or seek a peace bond). Figures from later in the process, such as conviction and sentencing, are even more distorted.

As noted above, there are four hypotheses for why the charging figures have risen, and only one of these is that the behaviour of Canadian girls has changed. Before we can contemplate the possibility that this is true, we must examine the other three hypotheses that may explain the increases. The base rate explanation for recent increases in female violence suggests that the small number of cases - 5,652 in 1998/99 - means that slight changes can translate into apparently dramatic and exaggerated increases. Indeed, the 127% increase quoted above has risen from 0.2% to 0.47% of the youthful population. In other words, in 1988 the rate of charging females for violent offences was 20.5 per 10,000 and it is now 47 per 10,000. The number of youths appearing before the youth courts remained constant during that time because the rate is being calculated on an increasingly smaller number of people in the 12 to 17 age category.

Alternatively, there could there be a double standard in how we see violent behaviour committed by girls that is played out in these charging statistics, reducing their utility as an indicator of girl violence. This double standard can work two ways. One view has it that female violence is more common than we think but it is not discussed, studied or addressed through criminal charges with the same frequency as male violence. Pearson (1997) suggests that female violence has been systematically ignored in favour of seeing females as victims who are violent in self-defence or under duress from a man. According to the chivalry hypothesis, the true incidence of female violence (and other crimes) is under-represented in official statistics because of biases in the reporting, arresting, charging, conviction and sentencing stages. Increases in official reports of female violence, in this view, reflect an erosion of the "chivalry" factors that some believe have traditionally resulted in disparate treatment of males and females at these key decision-making junctures. Equitable application of zero-tolerance policies in schools may also contribute to increases in the rate at which girls are charged for behaviours that previously were dealt with informally.

The double standard can also distort the charging rate for females through disparate decision making that inducts girls into the system for different reasons than boys. A discriminatory double standard is at work when girls are arrested, charged, detained, or convicted at greater rates or for more minor offences than are boys. Reitsma-Street (1993; 1999) is among those to argue that the behaviour of girls is judged to warrant charging in types of cases that are not seen as needing charges when perpetrated by boys. Incarcerating girls for administrative offences and generally making sentencing decisions based upon protecting girls rather than matching the penalty to the crime are two manifestations of gender bias (Corrado, Odgers and Cohen, 2000). In some jurisdictions, access to services by girls is not as extensive as for boys (Kempf-Leonard and Sample, 2000).

Investigating the differential treatment of boys and girls can be accomplished by examining police decision making after complaints are received. A precursor to such a study, which serves as an excellent example, is the work of Clark and Lewis (1977) who examined police decisions about complaints of what was then called rape. They examined all 117 rape complaints from one year in Toronto. Two thirds of these reports were classified by police as unfounded, a designation the researchers believed was questionable in 62 cases.
Where girls are concerned, research should examine the disposition of complaints and the extent to which cases are dealt with through unfounding, diversion without charge, clearance otherwise without charge, and charging.

3. Comparison of the "Violence" of Boys and Girls Charged with Violent Offences

When girls are charged with violent offences, two thirds (67%) are charged with what used to be called simple or common assault (Savoie, 1999), the least serious level of assault and one that can encompass behaviours such as spitting at someone. The figure for boys is 46%. In other words, it could well be that the so-called violent crimes of boys and girls are qualitatively different. If this is the case, then using police statistics to examine male versus female changes in the rate of violence obscures important information about the nature of female violence. Closer examination of the violent offences with which youth are charged could shed some light on differential severity, contexts, and motives as well as explain any disparity in police decision making.

4. Pathway Research

It may well be the case that girls find themselves involved with violence for distinctly different reasons than do boys. Several researchers have examined the pathways that bring young women into conflict with the law. For example, Daly (1992) identified five pathways to crime including women who were abused as children and respond with anger and possibly violence and women who are arrested after defending themselves against the attacks of intimate partners. A review of the pathway research concluded that the variable consistently identified as the first step in the criminal behaviour of women is victimization (Acoca, 1999).

Several themes emerge from the pathway research (Cunningham and Leschied, 1998), most strongly that of survival where criminal behaviour is seen as economically motivated, either to sustain a life on the street, to assist family finances or to seek the acceptance of others through acquisition of material goods (Sommers, 1995). Aggressive behaviour may be reflections of defensive adaptations to surviving with abuse. Two other themes are escape (through substance abuse, running away, early home leaving, early school leaving, suicide attempts) and stigma/self concept, leaving young women seeking love and acceptance among exploitative or anti-social subcultures, by having babies, or living with serial partners who share their use of substances, abuse them, or both.

5. Study Desistance

Using criminal charges for violent offences as the indicator, offending girls are younger than males and their criminal behaviour peaks earlier. The average age of young women who are charged by the police is 15, true of statistics at both the national and provincial (Ontario) levels (Correctional Service Canada, 1998). This has been a stable pattern in Ontario throughout the 1990s. Girls charged with violent offences tend to be 14 or 15 ( Savoie, 1999). The charging rate drops off for 16 year olds and again for 17 year olds (see Figure 1). In other words, if charging rates are a valid indicator, their patterns of criminal behaviour vary from boys in that they peak earlier and desist from crime sooner.

A small but intriguing body of research examines desistance: when, how and why people with histories of criminal behaviour stop. This is the inverse of the more typical approach that focuses on those most likely to continue with anti-social behaviour. This topic has been investigated using longitudinal study of offender populations (e.g., Kerner et al., 1997) and small samples of offenders (e.g., Arnold and Kay, 1999). Particularly promising for the present purpose would be the use of a life history approach in small samples (e.g., Farrall and Bowling, 1999) or studying the autobiographies of reformed offenders (e.g., Maruna, 1997). The few studies which have examined females (e.g., Uggen and Kruttschnitt, 1998; Sommers et al., 1994) suggest that the process of desistance is a long and complex one that involves the interaction of many factors. A female-centred approach to desistance research would focus on factors such as relationships, child bearing, employment, education, stability of housing, and adequacy of income.
Figure 1
Cases Heard by Youth Courts in Ontario (1994/95) by Sex
graph of cases heard in youth court

6. The Violence Begets Violence Hypothesis

It has been suggested by many observers that exposure to violence in one's childhood home is a powerful force that significantly raises the probability of violent perpetration or victimization. How this varies between boys and girls is still an open question, as is the role of various protective factors that may well mediate the relationship. However, criminal behaviour in young women is typically seen as part of an overall coping strategy that frequently has its roots in childhood abuse or neglect (see Gilfus, 1992). Acoca (1998: 59) describes victimization as "one of the most universally shared attributes of women in prison." Indeed, 16 and 17-year old young offenders in Ontario report high rates of childhood abuse and, despite their young age, abuse in relationships (see Table 1).

While no direct causal link between victimization and criminal behaviour among women has yet been identified (Widom, 1989a; Widom & Ames, 1994; Rivera & Widom, 1990), the correlation between abuse/neglect and crime is high (Widom, 1989) and the mechanisms that contribute to criminal behaviour have been described as both cause and consequence of abuse. These include substance abuse, family problems, education/employment problems and mental health issues.
Table 1
Self-report of Abuse Experiences, 84 Phase II Adolescent Women




ABUSE
Custody Sample (n=43) Community Sample (n=41)

Total
Physically abused as child 60.5% 24.4% 42.8%
Physically abused as adult 44.2% 29.3% 36.9%
Sexually abused as child 48.8% 36.6% 42.9%
Sexually abused as adult 27.9% 19.5% 23.8%
Source: Shaw (1994: 13)
Approaches to studying this issue would include the long-term, prospective study of abused girls and those exposed to family violence. It would also be possible to isolate the risk and protective factors associated with later violence because not all abused children become violent adults.

7. Evaluate the Effectiveness of Gender-specific Programs

Earlier in this century, the predominant assumption was that delinquency in girls was a consequence of lapsed morality, a factor linked in some periods to low intellectual capacity. Anti-social behaviour in girls was thought to be particularly problematic because of their reproductive capacity and the near certainty, as it was thought, of passing along criminal propensities to the next generation, either genetically or through bad child rearing. Intervention efforts focused on tests for venereal disease, training in domestic skills, and efforts to control their sexual behaviour. The latter could include institutionalization and, in some jurisdictions, sterilization.
Today, offending girls are treated much the same as their male counterparts. Some have suggested that the same principles of intervention that "work" for males should apply to women (Dowden & Andrews, 1999). However, the extension of general research findings to girls remains an open question because females constitute such a small proportion of the subjects in evaluation studies and meta-analyses (Koons, Burrow, Morash & Bynum, 1997). Many of the new and emerging approaches to programming for girls have grown out of an understanding of how girls are different from boys. While more basic research of a causal nature needs to be conducted, it appears that girls may well find their way to violent behaviour in significantly different ways than do boys and so treatment strategies should vary accordingly.

This realization has prompted a plethora of public discussion summed up by this question: "what about girls?" (Budnick & Shields-Fletcher, 1998). At this point, that question has not been answered with rigorous scientific studies that would unequivocally advance our understanding of what effective programs for females should look like, but there are many criticisms of the number, content, and variety of programs now available to females (Koons, Burrow, Morash & Bynum, 1997). Moreover, there is an emerging consensus on promising directions for programming derived from surveys of experts in the field and reviews of promising programs (e.g., Austin, Bloom & Donahue, 1992; Koons et al., 1997; Morash, Bynum & Koons, 1998).
In the United States, a comprehensive review of best practices by the Office for Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention (Greene, Peters & Associates, 1998) endorsed the need for girls-only, gender-specific programmes that aid transition into womanhood. Aspects of effective programming include addressing issues within the context of relationships (peers, family, school and community), increasing confidence, modelling and reinforcing positive messages about being female, challenging sex-role stereotyping, teaching girls they have many options in life, promoting health, fostering strengths and resiliency, and teaching skills in assertiveness, problem solving and relationships.

Gender-specific programming involves a concentrated effort to assist adolescent women in positive female development. Key aspects of gender-specific programming defined in the OJJDP review were:
  • taking into account the developmental needs of girls at adolescence, a critical stage for gender identity formation
  • nurturing and reinforcing "femaleness" as a positive identity with inherent strengths
  • providing girls with decision-making and life skills that will assist their development into womanhood
  • teaching positive relationship-building skills, given the importance that girls place on relationships
  • empowering girls to use their voice, to speak for themselves, and to recognize that they have choices
  • recognizing the dangers and risks that girls face because of gender by acknowledging that the lives of girl offenders may have been affected by sexism, victimization and exploitation, poverty and racism.
Clearly, a move to gender-specific programming is advocated in the American literature. The Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Act (1992) in the United States requires state governments seeking federal funding to have a plan for providing needed gender-specific services. Half of the states have done so already and the other half are in the process of doing so (Greene, Peters & Associates, 1998), although the pace of that progress is somewhat disappointing (Shelden, 1998). Some of the more common activities have been research, task forces and innovative pilot projects. One notable example is the Female Intervention Team in Baltimore, a unit of 13 probation officers that works only with young female probationers (Greene, Peters & Associates, 1998; Daniel, 1999). Implementation and evaluation of such programs, designed with an appreciation of the unique female pathways to aggression, would contribute to our understanding of how to intervene with violent girls.

8. Examine the Validity of Current Risk-prediction Schemes for Female Aggression

In the criminal justice systems of some jurisdictions, risk predictions instruments are used to perform a variety of functions that include case planning, facility placement, security level, release timing and intensity of intervention (Griffiths and Cunningham, 2000). Such instruments can be general or offence specific, and may vary according to the task or be generic for all decisions.
However, such instruments, when designed and normed on males, may have less utility for girls when compared with instruments adapted specifically to girls (Funk, 1999). First, some items might need to be weighted differently. For example, criminal values and peer influence on criminal behaviour may well be of little importance for girl offenders (Liu & Kaplan, 1999). Second, some variables may have to be added. For example, history of attempted suicide was the strongest predictor of violent recidivism in one group of female inmates and history of self-injury was correlated with recidivism in another (see Blanchette, 1997). While depression has traditionally been dismissed as a treatment target because it was not known to be correlated with criminal behaviour, at least one large-scale American study suggests that this conclusion may not apply to girls (Obeidallah & Earls, 1999).

Indeed, a recent review of the literature (Cunningham et al., 2000) determined that adolescent women share several risk markers with their male counterparts but that there are others that are unique to females that are not generally considered in most instruments. It would appear that the accuracy of predictions of future criminal behaviour can be enhanced by modifications based on an understanding of how women are different from male offenders (Uggen & Kruttschnitt, 1998). An Ontario study of the LSI-OR suggested that the cut-off scores used with men are not appropriate for women (Coulson et al., 1996) and this instrument has been revised in its commercial form (the LSI-R) to eliminate risk categories altogether for women. The SIR Scale is no longer used by the Correctional Service of Canada for women while its applicability to populations other than Caucasian males (and some offender groups) is being reconsidered (Cormier, 1997). More generally, the low levels of explained variance of the LSI (Nussbaum, 1999) and other methodological problems (Griffiths and Cunningham, 2000) suggest that further research could improve the predictive validity for all groups.

Greene, Peters and Associates (1998) described two projects now underway, funded with the assistance of the National Council on Crime and Delinquency (NCCD), to develop gender-specific assessment tools for use with girls in the juvenile justice system. The first is the Risk Assessment Instrument which objectively classifies a girl's risk of re-offending and can help decision makers and service providers target the resources best suited to the individual. The second instrument, the Strengths/Needs Assessment Instrument, helps service providers plan and deliver gender-specific interventions. They are being piloted in the Cook County Juvenile Probation Department, where the Juvenile Probation Department now has a Female Offender Unit that will use these gender-specific assessment tools.

9. Examine the Successes

In a related vein to the desistance research, studying the successful completers of a program, actually asking them why they managed to remain free of violent behaviour, is a strategy that is not often employed.

10. Content Analysis of Media Reports of Girl Violence

Finally, it would be informative to investigate the extent to which media reports of girls violence are reflective, in frequency and content, of the cases known to authorities.

Conclusion

This paper has advanced ten research activities to address several questions that have recently emerged as important: what is the incidence and prevalence of adolescent female violence in Canada today? ...are Canadian girls more aggressive and violent that in the past? ...if female violence is on the increase, why is that so? ...is female aggression caused by different mechanisms than male aggression? ...what interventions are effective in preventing violence by girls? ...what interventions are effective in reducing violence among aggressive girls? 

These are interesting questions for which there are no firm data that points to the answers. One national indicator - rate of charging of girls for interpersonal offences - suggests that violence among girls is on the increase. However, there are three rival plausible hypotheses to explain the changes: erosion of the chivalry double standard, increase of the discriminatory double standard and simple statistical artifact.

1. use longitudinal surveys of general population youth to determine normative levels of violence among youth
2. examine police decision making for disparity in how the aggression of boys and girls is responded to when charges are being contemplated
3. examine the different nature of assaults committed by boys and girls to determine the qualitative differences in behaviours which are categorized as "assault"
4. retroactively study samples of violent girls to examine, with each individual, the chain of life events (or pathways) that brought them to the context where they began to use violence
5. examine the factors associated with desistance from violent behaviour among the girls who were violent in early adolescence but who ceased using aggressive behaviour
6. investigate the connection between exposure to violence in the childhood home, experience of child abuse and later violence on a prospective sample of exposed and abused children
7. implement and evaluate gender-specific programs for girls
8. develop and test assessment and prediction instruments that are designed with an understanding of the correlates of female aggression
9. study the successful completers of intervention programs to determine why they were able to eliminate their aggressive behaviour
10. conduct content analysis of media reports to determine if the frequency and nature of reports of girl violence match the known cases
This program of research activities would add to our newly emerging understanding of how to prevent and intervene with violent behaviour by girls in Canada.

References Cited

Acoca, L. (1999). Investing in Girls: A 21st Century Strategy. Juvenile Justice, VI(1): 3-13.
Acoca, L. (1998). Defusing the Time Bomb: Understanding and Meeting the Growing Health Care Needs of Incarcerated Women in America. Crime & Delinquency, 44 (1): 44-69.
American Psychological Association, Commission on Violence and Youth (1993). Violence and Youth: Psychology's Response. Washington DC: American Psychological Association.
Arnold, B.L. and Kay F.M. (1999). Early Transition Stages and Heterogeneity in Criminal Careers among Young Offenders. Canadian Review of Sociology & Anthropology, 36(2): 157-177.
Artz, S. (1998). Sex, Power, and the Violent School Girl. Toronto: Trifolium Books.
Austin, J., Bloom, B., and Donahue, T. (1992). Female Offenders in the Community: An Analysis of Innovative Strategies and Programs. Washington DC: National Institute of Corrections.
Blanchette, K. 1997. Classifying Female Offenders for Correctional Interventions. Forum on Corrections Research. 9(1): 36-41.
Bloom, B. and S. Covington (1998). Gender-specific Programming for Female Offenders: What is it and Why is it Important? Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Society of Criminology, Washington DC, November 11 to 14.
Budnick, K.J. and E. Shields-Fletcher (1998). OJJDP Fact Sheet #84: What About Girls? Washington DC: U.S. Department of Justice.
Clark, L. and Lewis, D. (1973). Rape: The Price of Coercive Sexuality. Toronto: The Women's Press.
Corrado, R., Odgers, C. and Cohen, I.M. (2000). The Incarceration of Female Young Offenders: Protection for Whom? Canadian Journal of Criminology, 42(2): 189-207.
Correctional Service Canada (1998). Female Young Offenders in Canada, Revised Edition. Ottawa: Research Branch, Correctional Service of Canada.
Coulson, G., Flacqua, G., Nutbrown, V. Giulekas, D., and Cudjoe, F. (1996). Predictive Utility of the LSI for Incarcerated Female Offenders. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 23(3): 427-439.
Cunningham, A., Baker, L., Mazaheri, N., Ashbourne, L., VanBrunschot, M. and Currie, M. (2000), Best Practice Programming for Phase II Young Offenders: A Literature Review. London: Centre for Children and Families in the Justice System.
Cunningham A. Hatch and Griffiths, C.T. Griffiths (1997). Canadian Criminal Justice: A Primer. Toronto: Harcourt Brace.
Cunningham, A., Jaffe, P., Baker, L., Dick, T., Malla, S., Mazaheri, N. and Poisson, S. (1998). Theory-derived Explanation of Male Violence Against Female Partners: Literature Update and Related Implications for Treatment and Evaluation. London: London Family Court Clinic.
Cunningham, A. and A.W. Leschied (1998). Thinking About Choices: Program Recommendations for Women in Conflict with the Law with Histories of Abuse Victimization. London: London Family Court Clinic [prepared for Elizabeth Fry Society, Hamilton Branch].
Daly, K. (1992). Women's Pathways to Felony Court: Feminist Theories of Lawbreaking and Problems of Representation. Review of Law and Women's Studies, 2: 11-52.
Daniel, M.D. (1999). The Female Intervention Team. Juvenile Justice, VI(1): 14-20.
Dowden, C. and D. Andrews (1999). What Works for Female Offenders: A Meta-analytic Review. Crime & Delinquency, 45(4): 438-452.
Farrall S. and Bowling B. (1999). Structuration, Human Development and Desistance from Crime. British Journal of Criminology, 39(2): 253-268.
Funk S.J. (1999). Risk Assessment for Juveniles on Probation - A Focus on Gender. Criminal Justice & Behavior, 26(1):44-68.
Gilfus, Mary E. (1992) From Victims to Survivors to Offenders: Women's Routes of Entry and Immersion into Street Crime. Women & Criminal Justice, 4(1): 63-89.
Greene, Peters and Associates (October, 1998). Guiding Principles for Promising Female Programming: An Inventory of Best Practices. Washington DC: Office for Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.
Griffiths, C.T. and A. Cunningham (2000). Canadian Corrections. Toronto: ITP Nelson.
Kempf-Leonard, K. and L.L. Sample (2000). Disparity Based on Sex: Is Gender-Specific Treatment Warranted? Justice Quarterly, 17(1): 89-128.
Kerner, H.-J., Weitekamp, E.G. and Thomas, J. (1997). Patterns of Criminality and Alcohol Abuse: Results of the Tuebingen Criminal Behaviour Development Study. Criminal Behaviour & Mental Health, 7(4): 401-420.
Koons, Barbara A., John D. Burrow, Merry Morash and Tim Bynum (1997) Expert and offender perceptions of program elements linked to successful outcomes for incarcerated women. Crime & Delinquency, (43)4: 512-532.
Leschied, A., Cummings, A., VanBrunschot, M., Cunningham, A. and Saunders, A. (2000). Female Adolescent Aggression: A Review of the Correlates of Aggression. Ottawa: Solicitor General Canada.
Liu, X.R., and Kaplan, H.B. (1999). Explaining the Gender Difference in Adolescent Delinquent Behavior: A Longitudinal Test of Mediating Mechanisms. Criminology, 37(1): 195-215.
Maruna, S. (1997). Going Straight: Desistance from Crime and Life Narratives of Reform. In A. Lieblich and R. Josselson (Eds), The Narrative Study of Lives. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, pp. 59-93.
Morash, M., Bynum, T.S., and Koons, B.A. (1998). Women Offenders: Programming Needs and Promising Approaches, Research in Brief. Washington DC: National Institute of Justice, U.S. Department of Justice.
Nussbaum, D. (1999). Review of the Psychology of Criminal Conduct. Canadian Journal of Criminology, 41(4): 544-564.
Obeidallah, D. and Earls, F.J. (1999). Adolescent Girls: The Role of Depression in the Development of Delinquency. Washington DC: Office of Justice Programs, U.S. Department of Justice.
Pearson, P. (1997). When She was Bad: Violent Women and the Myth of Innocence. Toronto: Random House Canada.
Pepler, D.J. and Craig, W. (1999). Aggressive Girls: Development of Disorder and Outcomes. Toronto: The LaMarsh Research Centre, York University.
Puzzanchera, C.M. (February, 2000). Self-reported Delinquency by 12-year-olds, 1997. OJJDP Fact Sheet. Washington DC: Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention, U.S. Department of Justice.
Reitsma-Street, M. (1999). Justice for Canadian Girls: A 1990s Update. Canadian Journal of Criminology, 41(3): 335-363.
Reitsma-Street, M. (1993). Canadian Youth Court Charges and Dispositions for Females Before and After the Implementation of the Young Offenders Act. Canadian Journal of Criminology, 35: 437-458.
Rivera, B., & Spatz Widom, C. (1990). Childhood victimization and violent offending. Violence & Victims, 5 (1): 19-35.
Savoie, J. (1999). Youth Violent Crime. Canadian Centre for Justice Statistics: Juristat, 19(13).
Shaw, Margaret (1994). Ontario Women in Conflict with the Law: A Survey of Women in Institutions and Under Community Supervision in Ontario. Ministry of the Solicitor General and Correctional Services.
Shaw, M. (1994b). Ontario Women in Conflict with the Law Subsidiary Report: Young Offenders. Toronto: Ministry of Correctional Services.
Shelden, R.G. (1998). Gender Bias in the Juvenile Justice System. Juvenile and Family Court Journal, 49(1): 11-26.
Simon, R.J. (1975). Women and Crime. Lexington MA: D.C. Health and Company.
Snyder, H.N. (December, 1999). Juvenile Justice Bulletin: Juvenile Arrests 1998. Washington DC: Office for Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention, U.S. Department of Justice.
Sommers, E.K. (1995). Voices From Within: Women Who Have Broken the Law. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Sommers, I., Baskin, D. R. and Fagan, J. (1994). Getting Out of the Life: Crime Desistance by Female Street Offenders. Deviant Behavior, 15(2): 125-149.
Statistics Canada (2000). Youth Court Statistics 1998/99. The Daily, 29 May.
Statistics Canada (1999). National Longitudinal Survey of Children and Youth: Transition into Adolescence 1996/97. The Daily, 6 July.
Tremblay, R.E., Boulerice, B., Harden, P.W, McDuff, P., Pérusse, D., Pihl, R.O. and Zoccolillo, M. (1996). Do Children in Canada Become More Aggressive as they Approach Adolescence? Growing Up in Canada: National Longitudinal Survey of Children and Youth. Ottawa: Human Resources Development Canada and Statistics Canada, pp. 127-136.
Uggen C. and Kruttschnitt C. (1998). Crime in the Breaking: Gender Differences in Desistance. Law & Society Review, 32(2): 339-366.
Widom, C. Spatz (1989a) Child Abuse, Neglect and Violent Criminal Behavior. Criminology, 27 (2): 251-269.
Widom, C. Spatz (1989b) The Cycle of Violence. Science, 244 (14): 160-166.
Widom, C. Spatz and M. Ashley Ames (1994) Criminal Consequences of Childhood Sexual Victimization. Child Abuse & Neglect, 18 (4): 303-318.

Warren, M., (ed.). (1981). Comparing Female and Male Offenders. Beverly Hills CA: Sage.

1. The Uniform Crime Reporting System of Statistics Canada includes these crimes in the category of "violent" offences: assaults, robbery, sexual offences, criminal harassment, extortion, attempted murder and homicide.